● Heat pumps · Heating · Cooling · Private

Heating & cooling system
cost comparison and payback

Compare operating costs and payback using annual energy demand, seasonal efficiency ranges and tariffs you control.

✓ No sign-up✓ Browser-based✓ Instant results
01 · Comparable assumptions

Infer useful heat from an annual bill

Use a complete year of current energy use so seasonal cycling is reflected before comparing a heat pump.

Current heating system
Proposed heat pump
Projection assumptions

No escalation is applied unless you enter it. Maintenance, standing charges and efficiency are held unchanged through the projection.

Private comparisonEnergy use, tariffs, costs, equipment ratings and results stay in this browser and are not included in analytics.

Designed around uncertainty

Compare delivered comfort—not just appliance wattage

A heating or cooling system cycles with weather, thermostat settings and building load. This calculator starts from annual demand, converts each rating to a comparable efficiency ratio and shows low, central and high replacement outcomes.

01

Calibrate the baseline

Use a full year of measured energy or a documented annual useful-demand estimate. Do not combine partial seasons.

02

Use seasonal ratings

Prefer SCOP, SEER2, HSPF2 or another official seasonal value for the equipment and climate basis being considered.

03

Compare incremental cost

Payback should use the additional cost above the alternative replacement—not the proposed system’s entire purchase price.

Important limitations

Heating and cooling comparison FAQ

Why does the calculator require low, central and high efficiency values?

Actual seasonal performance changes with climate, equipment design, controls, defrost, auxiliary heat, ducting and installation quality. A range avoids presenting one uncertain value as a prediction.

Are COP, SCOP, SEER2 and HSPF2 interchangeable?

No. They come from different test methods and seasons. The known-demand workflow converts the selected rating to a common energy ratio for arithmetic, but the source climate and test procedure still matter.

Does the payback include financing, tax or equipment life?

No. It is a simple payback and cash projection based on the costs and price-change assumptions entered. Financing, tax, equipment replacement, residual value and unentered maintenance are excluded.

Can this tool size a heat pump or recommend a system?

No. Equipment sizing and suitability require a qualified assessment of the building, climate, distribution system and design conditions.

Does Utilaroo supply tariffs or rebates?

No. No default tariff, rebate, climate zone or efficiency is applied. Use current figures from bills, official rating labels and verified proposals.

Method, example and limitations

Understand the result before using it

Use this calculator to compare annual operating-cost scenarios for heating or cooling systems from measured energy or known useful demand. It cannot size equipment, assess a building, forecast weather, verify an installation or recommend a system.

01 · Calculation method

What the tool does

The model converts an existing system’s input energy and efficiency into useful annual demand. It then divides that demand by the replacement efficiency range to estimate replacement input energy. Tariffs, standing charges and maintenance produce annual cost; simple payback uses incremental upfront cost divided by annual savings.

02 · Worked example

Deliver 6,000 kWh of annual useful heat

  1. An 85% baseline needs about 7,059 kWh of fuel input.
  2. A heat pump with seasonal COP 3.5 needs about 1,714 kWh of electricity.
  3. At $0.12/kWh fuel and $0.35/kWh electricity, energy cost is about $847 versus $600 before fixed charges.

How to read it: Seasonal efficiency—not peak wattage—drives this comparison. Climate, sizing, duct losses, defrost, controls, auxiliary heat and installation quality can move real performance outside a brochure value.

Assumptions used
  • Annual useful demand is comparable between systems.
  • Efficiency figures come from an appropriate seasonal test or assessment.
  • Standing charges disappear only when the relevant service is actually disconnected.
Common mistakes to avoid
  • Comparing input wattage without delivered heating or cooling.
  • Using a single laboratory COP as a year-round guarantee.
  • Calculating payback from the full purchase price instead of incremental replacement cost.